An emerging orientation

Why am I so excited about the HKW Summer School? Because it represents an attempt to take some cultural initiative: this is “us” showing what we’ve got and what we can do with it, and showing-by-doing that what can be done in this way is actually worth doing.

I don’t expect everyone to be convinced by such a demonstration – in fact, I expect quite a few people to be dismayed about it, to feel that this is an upstart, renegade movement with distinctly not-for-People-Like-Us values and practices (maths! logics! don’t we know Lawvere* was a worse fascist than Heidegger?). It’s likely that not a few leftish PLUs will be rocking up any moment now to tell us all to curb our enthusiasm. But a glance over the history of Marxist thought will show that there have been plenty of times and places in which the initiative has indeed been held by rationalists – albeit often by warring rationalists, who disagreed ferociously with each other about how a rational politics was to be construed and practised. It’s not at all clear that the present moment, which places such overriding importance on affective tone, is not in fact the anomaly. That’s not to say that we should ditch everything that has declared itself over the past decade – on the contrary, it represents a vast, complex, necessary and unfinished project to which we should aim to contribute meaningfully. But we can only do so by approaching that project from a perspective which it does not encompass, and is hugely unwilling – and perhaps unable – to recognise as valid. To do so requires confidence, of a kind that those who are already confident in their moral standing will find unwarranted and overweening. We are going to be talked down to a lot; we are going to be called names; we are going to have to develop strong memetic defenses against the leftish words-of-power that grant the wielder an instant power of veto over unwelcome ideas. We have a lot to prove. Calculemus!

  • a fairly hardcore Maoist, as it happens.

One thought on “An emerging orientation”

Comments are closed.